Prenatal exposure to methyl mercury in fish is not associated with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) phenotypic behaviors. This is the result of a large cohort study of mothers and children in the Indian Ocean nation Seychelles, where residents consume 10 times the amount of ocean fish as U.S. residents.
Mercury in fish. Consumption advice is for
(graphic credit: Wikipedia)
Mercury, entering our environment both from natural and anthropogenic sources, can be transformed by microbes to methylmercury, which can be accumulated in aquatic organisms, leading to relatively high concentrations in bigger predatory fish (see picture to the left). Although vaccines have been suggested as a source of mercury exposure, the main source of exposure to organic mercury in humans is through methyl mercury found in fish. The new study:
Since Methylmercury is a strong neurotoxin, exposure through the diet is of great concern, and health organizations recommend to restrict the consumption of fish depending on the type of fish and the vulnerability of the consumer. Despite the great concerns, scientists have great difficulties to prove any problems related to this intake. Therefore the "sentinel" population of the Rebublic of Seychelles, an island chain lying northeast of Madagascar has long attracted scientific interest. As islanders, the people of Seychelles consume a lot of fish - 10 times more than the average North American or European - and much of what they eat contains methylmercury. Although concentrations are low, the total amounts of methylmercury taken up are greater than much of the rest of the world eats, resulting in an intake about 20 times higher than that of an American.
This special situation of 87,000 people naturally consuming a fish-rich diet attracted the attention of epidemiologists already in the 1980s, when the Seychelles Child Development Study was launched to examine the developmental effects of this low-level dietary mercury exposure.
To examine whether consuming too much fish during pregnancy is associated with autism, Davidson and colleagues evaluated 1,784 young people and their mothers, enrolled in the study from 1986 to 2001. For the evaluation, the researchers used the Social Communication Questionnaire, a 40-item questionnaire widely used to screen people for ASD symptoms. Although not a diagnostic test, a score of 15 or higher warrants further evaluation. The original publication
Maternal hair samples collected around the time of birth were used to assess prenatal exposure to methyl mercury. A subset of 532 children (mean age 10 years) were also administered the Social Responsiveness Scale, a 65-item scale designed to recognize ASD symptoms in social settings. A score of 70 or greater in males and 65 or greater in females indicates a possible ASD. The primary endpoint was Social Communication Questionnaire scores in relation to mothers' prenatal mercury levels.
Study participants had an average prenatal methyl mercury level of 8.4 parts per million, and average score on the Social Communication Questionnaire was 8.0. Approximately 8% of participants scored 15 or higher on the Social Communication Questionnaire.
Average prenatal methyl mercury exposure for the 532 participants who were administered the Social Responsiveness Scale was 6.7 parts per million. The mean score on that test was 57.6, with 34% of participants scoring above the cut-off for possible autism.
Using linear and nonlinear regression analyses, the researchers found no consistent correlation between prenatal exposure to methyl mercury and scores on ASD screening instruments.
"This study shows no consistent association in children with mothers with mercury levels that were six to 10 times higher than those found in the U.S. and Europe," study investigator Philip Davidson, PhD, an emeritus professor at University of Rochester Medical Center said in a press release. "This is a sentinel population and if it does not exist here than it probably does not exist."
As with similar studies, also this one comes with several caveats. Primarily because of the decades-long period of the study and variations in data collection over time, the researchers couldn’t adjust for all of the possible variables that might have skewed the analysis. One thing they note is that the study population comes from an area with almost 100% vaccination uptake and where vaccines contain thimerosal, so exposure to thimerosal–which contains a different form of mercury was considered to be consistent across the group.
A review of earlier studies on the developmental effects of prenatal mercury exposure found inconsistencies (see J.L. Jacobson 2001) , which were ascribed to differences in study design. Because prospective epidemiological studies are often hampered by limited control over confounding and other factors, including unmeasured between cohort differences in genetic vulnerability and nutritional adequacy, interferences about toxicity often depend heavily on a qualitative assessment of the weight of the evidence from multiple studies.
E. Van Wijngaarden. P.W. Davidson, T.H. Smith, K. Evans, K. Yost, T. Love, S.W. Thurston, G.E. Watson, G. Zareba, C.M. Burns, C.F. Shamlaye, G.J. Myers, Autism Spectrum Disorder Phenotypes and Prenatal Exposure to Methylmercury
, Epidemiology. 2013; doi: 10.1097/EDE.0b013e31829d2651
. Related studies
G.E. Watson, K. Evans, S.W. Thurston, E. van Wijngaarden, J.M.W. Wallace, E.M. McSorley, M.P. Bonham, M.S. Mulhern, A.J. McAfee, P.W. Davidson, C.F. Shamlaye, J.J. Strain, T. Love, G. Zareba, G.J. Myers, Prenatal exposure to dental amalgam in the Seychelles Child Development Nutrition Study: associations with neurodevelopmental outcomes at 9 and 30 months
, Neurotoxicology, 33 (2012) 1511–1517. doi: 10.1016/j.neuro.2012.10.001
P.W. Davidson, D.A. Cory-Slechta, S.W. Thurston, Li-Shan Huang, C.F. Shamlaye, D. Gunzler, G. Watson, E. van Wijngaarden, G. Zareba, Fish consumption and prenatal methylmercury exposure: cognitive and behavioral outcomes in the main cohort at 17 years from the Seychelles child development study
, Neurotoxicology, 32 (2011) 711–717. doi: 10.1016/j.neuro.2011.08.003
S.T. Schultz, Does thimerosal or other mercury exposure increase the risk
for autism? A review of current literature
, Acta Neurobiol. Exp. (Wars), 70 (2010) 187–195. available from: http://www.ane.pl/pdf/7023.pdf
I. Hertz-Picciotto, P.G. Green, L. Delwiche, R. Hansen, C. Walker, I.N. Pessah, Blood mercury concentrations in CHARGE Study children with and without autism
, Environ. Health Perspect, 118 (2010) 161–166. doi: 10.1289/ehp.0900736
P.W. Davidson, J.J. Strain, G.J. Myers, Neurodevelopmental effects of maternal nutritional status and exposure to methylmercury from eating fish during pregnancy
, Neurotoxicology, 29 (2008) 767–775. doi: 10.1016/j.neuro.2008.06.001
Y. Kawamura, O. Takahashi, T. Ishii, Reevaluating the incidence of pervasive developmental disorders: impact of elevated rates of detection through implementation of an integrated system of screening in Toyota, Japan
, Psychiatry Clin. Neurosci., 62 (2008) 152–159.
M.F. Blaxill, L. Redwood, S. Bernard, Thimerosal and autism? A plausible hypothesis that should not be dismissed,
Med. Hypotheses, 62 (2004) 788–794. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2003.11.033
M. Hornig, D. Chian, W.I. Lipkin, Neurotoxic effects of postnatal thimerosal are mouse strain dependen
t, Mol. Psychiatry, 9 (2004) 833–845. doi: 10.1038/sj.mp.4001529
Joseph L. Jacobson, Contending with Contradictory Data in a Risk Assessment Context: The Case of Methylmercury
, Neurotoxicoloy, 22 (2001) 667-675. doi: 10.1016/S0161-813X(01)00040-7
S. Bernard, A. Enayati, L. Redwood, H. Roger, T. Binstock, Autism: a novel form of mercury poisoning
, Med. Hypotheses, 56 (2001) 462–471. doi: 10.1054/mehy.2000.1281
G.J. Myers, P.W. Davidson, C. Cox, Neurodevelopmental outcomes of Seychellois children sixty-six months after in utero exposure to methylmercury from a maternal fish diet: pilot study
, Neurotoxicology, 16 (1995) 639–652.
G.J. Myers, D.O. Marsh, C. Cox, A pilot neurodevelopmental study of Seychellois children following in utero exposure to methylmercury from a maternal fish diet
, Neurotoxicology, 16 (1995) 629–638.
C.F. Shamlaye, D.O. Marsh, G.J. Myers, The Seychelles child development study on neurodevelopmental outcomes in children following in utero exposure to methylmercury from a maternal fish diet: background and demographics
, Neurotoxicology, 16 (1995) 597–612.
G.J. Myers, D.O. Marsh, P.W. Davidson, Main neurodevelopmental study of Seychellois children following in utero exposure to methylmercury from a maternal fish diet: outcome at six months
, Neurotoxicology, 16 (1995) 653–664. Related EVISA Resources
Link database: Mercury exposure through the diet Link database: Environmental cycling of mercury Link database: Toxicity of Organo-mercury compounds Link database: Research projects related to organo-mercury compounds Related EVISA News April 2, 2013: JRC validates simple method to monitor methylmercury in fish March 13, 2013: FDA rejects petition to change methylmercury standard in seafood January 14, 2013: Mercury Levels in Humans and Fish Around the World Regularly Exceed Health Advisory Levels December 24, 2012: Mercury in food – EFSA updates advice on risks for public health
December 9, 2012: Mercury in fish more dangerous than previously
believed; Scientists urge for effective treaty ahead of UN talks October 12, 2012: Prenatal mercury intake linked to ADHD
July 31, 2012: FDA Lands in Court Over Mercury in Fish June 17, 2012: Factors Affecting Methylmercury Accumulation in the Food Chain March 1, 2012: High levels of mercury in newborns likely from mothers eating contaminated fish October 15, 2011: Mercury pollution in the Great Lakes region -- nearly forgotten, but not gone August 16, 2010: Methylmercury: What have we learned from Minamata Bay? August 21, 2009: USGS Study Reveals Mercury Contamination in Fish Nationwide May 3, 2009: Ocean mercury on the rise February 11, 2009: Mercury in Fish is a Global Health Concern October 30, 2008: Precautionary approach to methylmercury needed
March 11, 2007: Methylmercury contamination of fish warrants worldwide public warning October 9, 2006: Linking atmospheric mercury to methylmercury in fish August 16, 2006: Mercury pollution threatens health worldwide, scientists say June 8, 2006: Methylmercury in fish: Can you cook it out ? May 3, 2006: Texas Study Relates Autism to Environmental Mercury February 17, 2006: Study shows link between clear lakes and methylmercury contamination in fish
February 9, 2006: Study show high levels of mercury in women related to fish consumption August 29, 2005: Is methyl mercury limiting the delight of
seafood ? - To answer this question is a challenge for elemental
speciation analysis January 12, 2005: Number of fish meals is a good predictor for the mercury found in hair of environmental journalists April 27, 2004: New kind of mercury found in fish April 27, 2004: FDA/EPA recommends pregnant women to restrict their fish consumption because of methylmercury content
last time modified: Juzly 29, 2013